A poster has been circulating on social media in recent weeks, fronted by an “accredited financial advisor” urging Kenyans to “convince your good employer” to move their Tier II NSSF contributions to a private pension fund. The pitch is simple and, on its face, compelling: the government pays 5.4%, we pay 11–12%, no extra charges, so why wouldn’t you switch? ICEA Lion is not alone in this campaign. Britam and several other private fund managers have run near-identical messaging over the past year, all built around the same comparison.
The trouble is that the comparison is false, and it is false in a way that matters enormously to the retirement security of ordinary workers.
The number that gives the game away
NSSF Kenya recently announced a net return of 17% for the 2024/2025 financial year on members’ savings. This is not a marketing claim; it is a declared, audited return on the Fund’s investment portfolio, and it has reportedly rattled private pension providers precisely because it undercuts the narrative that government-run pensions are the weaker option.
Industry commentary following the announcement noted that matching a 17% return would be difficult for most diversified, prudently managed private schemes, and urged the private sector to stop competing on headline numbers and instead talk about risk-adjusted returns, governance, and portability.
That is a telling admission. When an industry’s own analysts concede that they cannot beat the number and instead advise their members to change the subject, it should give any worker pause before signing a transfer form based on a poster claiming the government “only” offers 5.4%.
Where does the 5.4% figure even come from? It appears to be either an outdated reference to a specific bond or guaranteed-fund benchmark, or a figure cherry-picked from a weaker year, presented as if it were NSSF’s permanent, fixed ceiling. NSSF’s returns, like those of any pension fund, vary year to year depending on market performance. Quoting a single low year while ignoring a 17% year, and calling it “the government’s rate” as though it were a fixed interest account, is not an honest comparison. It is a sales tactic.
Security is not a marketing add-on; it is the entire point of a pension
A pension exists to still be there in thirty years. That is the actual product being sold, and it is where the private pitch is weakest.
NSSF is established by an Act of Parliament, regulated by the Retirement Benefits Authority, and backed by the state’s oversight machinery. Its asset base includes large-scale, income-generating property and infrastructure investments accumulated over decades, giving it a scale and diversification that most single private schemes cannot easily replicate. Contributions are pooled nationally, spreading risk across millions of members rather than concentrating it in one employer-sponsored fund.
Private pension schemes are not inherently dishonest vehicles, and many are competently run. But they are commercial products. They carry management fees, they depend on the performance and continuity of a single fund manager, and their “guaranteed” rates are frequently guaranteed only in the way that any promise from a for-profit institution is guaranteed, subject to the fine print, the solvency of the insurer, and the specific fund chosen. “No extra charges” on a transfer says nothing about the ongoing management fees that get deducted from returns every single year regardless of performance.
Why the pressure campaign should worry Kenyans
The most concerning element of this campaign is not the interest rate claim itself but the tactic: individual agents are being incentivized to pressure employers into moving Tier II contributions for entire workforces, often on commission. Workers rarely see the fund fact sheets, fee structures, or five-year performance history of the scheme being pushed. They see a poster with a smiling agent, a WhatsApp number, and a comparison chart engineered to make a state pension fund look like a bad deal.
Employees have the legal right to have their Tier II contributions redirected to a private scheme approved by the Retirement Benefits Authority, and for some, a well-run occupational scheme may genuinely make sense. But that decision should rest on audited fund performance, fee disclosures, and RBA-approved documentation, not on a single misleading percentage on a Facebook or WhatsApp poster.
Before any employer or employee “chanukas” and signs a transfer, they would do well to ask the agent for the specific fund’s five-year audited return history, its total expense ratio, and how that compares honestly to NSSF’s actual declared returns, not a stale, cherry-picked number designed to make the switch feel obvious.
Related Content: Your Future Self Will Thank You: A Simple Guide To NSSF Voluntary Membership in Kenya

