Boda Boda

High Court Shields Watu Credit from Sh705,550 Compensation Claim Over Boda Boda Crash

A Trans Nzoia woman whose leg was shattered in a boda boda crash six years ago must now pursue a rider who never turned up in court for her Sh705,550 compensation. The High Court has ruled that the company that financed his motorcycle cannot be made to pay.

In Kitale, Justice Joseph Were set aside a magistrate’s finding that Watu Credit Limited was jointly liable with the borrower, Felix N. Chesoli, for injuries to Sarah Nanjala Kunguru. She was a pillion passenger on a motorcycle that was rammed from behind at Maili Tatu, on the Kitale–Webuye road, on July 23, 2020.

On the same day, November 12, Justice E. Ogola in Nairobi dismissed a motorist’s bid to make Watu Nominees Company Limited answer for a Sh800,000 award. He held that “bare registered ownership by a financier does not generate vicarious liability without evidence of agency, control, or use for the financier’s purposes.”

The twin rulings add to a line of High Court decisions protecting lenders who keep motorcycles registered in their names until the loans are repaid.

Ms Nanjala suffered compound fractures of the right tibia and fibula and was left with a 19cm scar. An eyewitness told the trial court that the motorcycle behind hit the one she was on and that its rider fled. Mr Chesoli never responded to the suit.

In October 2024, Resident Magistrate Irene Kabuteh held Watu Credit and Mr Chesoli jointly liable. She noted that the company was the registered owner and that he had stopped repaying the loan in April 2020, three months before the crash.

Watu Credit’s branch administrator testified that Mr Chesoli bought the motorcycle on credit for Sh162,377, repayable in weekly instalments of Sh2,662, and rode it himself.

The loan agreement allowed the lender to install a tracking device, switch off the motorcycle remotely, arrange insurance at the borrower’s cost and repossess it if he defaulted. Justice Were held that these were “mechanisms for protecting the collateral and securing repayment and nothing about who rides the motorcycle where or when or for whose purposes.”

“The fact that the loan remained unpaid and the Appellant remained the registered owner did not on its own establish vicarious liability,” the judge ruled.

He found that Ms Nanjala had not proved that Mr Chesoli was the company’s “servant or agent”. Mr Chesoli alone must now pay the award, and Ms Nanjala must pay Watu Credit’s costs of the trial.

The judge said his decision did not affect “such rights as the 1st Respondent may have against the insurer of the suit motorcycle”. The judgment does not name the insurer.

In the Nairobi case, motorist Salome Wangari Kihara was found wholly to blame for a December 2024 collision on North Airport Road near Cabanas. Pillion passenger Mary Ouma Achieng fractured her left femur in the crash. Ms Kihara wanted Watu Nominees, the motorcycle’s registered owner, to indemnify her.

She argued that the company had not registered its security interest under the Movable Property Security Rights Act and was not a licensed credit provider. Justice Ogola said the Act “has no bearing on tortious liability to a third-party stranger” and that “regulatory banking status does not create tortious liability.”

Both judges relied on a 2025 decision by Justice Mrima that cleared Watu Nominees on similar grounds.

Justice Ogola’s ruling is final under the Small Claims Court Act.

Related Content: Watu Cuts Motorcycle Deposit To 27%: New Riders Save Up to Sh16,000 Upfront

Business Watch Team

Business Watch Team

Business Watch is an online business portal that is set to marry both the traditional media and the digital media and bring them under one umbrella

Leave a Reply

Tweets by Business Watch

Archives

About

Business Watch is an online business portal that is set to marry both the traditional media and the digital media and bring them under one umbrella.

Ad

Our Detailed Reports

  1. [download id=”20060″]

Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from around Kenya and East Africa

Latest from Governance

Don't Miss