Jilk

Court Cracks Whip As Ksh 2.4 Billion Kisumu Brewery Dispute Deepens

The High Court has tightened the screws in the simmering legal war between JILK Construction Limited and multiple high-profile parties, ordering that all applications be physically served within one day and responses filed within three days.

Justice Francis Muthuku issued the directive after lawyers complained they had learned of parts of the latest suit through social media rather than formal service. JILK’s legal team insisted documents had been sent via email. The judge ruled that physical service must now be effected immediately, with further directions set for February 24. He also indicated that an application seeking to strike out Diageo PLC from the case would be heard on priority.

In the fresh application, JILK wants the court to lift orders issued in December 2024 that barred the arbitrator in its dispute with Kenya Breweries Limited (KBL) from delivering an award. The construction firm has also attempted to rope in executives from East African Breweries Limited (EABL).

Appearing for Diageo, lawyer Njoroge Regeru argued the company has no contractual relationship with JILK. Senior Counsel Prof. Githu Muigai, representing EABL executives, told the court he had not been served. KBL’s lawyer, Kamau Karori, maintained that the brewer could not substantively respond since the matter remains under arbitration.

Behind the procedural fireworks lies a bitter commercial fallout dating back to November 2019, when JILK terminated its contract with KBL over construction works at the Kisumu Brewery, having already received KSh1.2 billion. The dispute initially centered on KSh163 million. But after arbitration commenced in February 2020 under an arbitrator appointed by the Architectural Association of Kenya (AAK), the claim ballooned to KSh2.4 billion — a staggering 1,372 percent increase.

KBL has accused the arbitrator, Mutinda Mutuku, of conflict of interest and financial entanglements with JILK before and during the arbitration. The brewer alleges payments totaling hundreds of millions of shillings were made to the arbitrator prior to his appointment, claims Mutuku has acknowledged prior professional engagements with JILK but denies wrongdoing.

The brewer further claims inflated fees, questionable billing practices, and a compromised arbitration process. The allegations prompted KBL to enjoin AAK, the Directorate of Criminal Investigations, and the Commission on Administrative Justice as interested parties.

As the courtroom battle intensifies, the core dispute between JILK and KBL remains unheard — buried under a growing mountain of applications, counter-allegations, and procedural skirmishes. February 24 now looms as the next pivotal date in a case that continues to raise serious questions about corporate governance, arbitration integrity, and the high stakes of Kenya’s construction and beverage industries.

Related Content: The Attack On The Jilk Construction Whistleblower Is A Threat to Justice

Business Watch Team

Business Watch Team

Business Watch is an online business portal that is set to marry both the traditional media and the digital media and bring them under one umbrella

Tweets by Business Watch

Archives

About

Business Watch is an online business portal that is set to marry both the traditional media and the digital media and bring them under one umbrella.

Ad

Our Detailed Reports

  1. [download id=”20060″]

Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from around Kenya and East Africa

Latest from Governance

Don't Miss