NSSF

A Court That Corrected Itself: What the Setting Aside of the May 29 NSSF Ruling Means for Millions of Kenyan Workers

The Ruling in Plain Terms

On Friday, June 26, 2026, a three-judge bench of the Court of Appeal comprising Justices Wanjiru Karanja, Kihara Kariuki Minoti, and Pauline Nyamweya did something rare in the annals of Kenyan jurisprudence: they admitted that their own court had made a mistake, and they fixed it.

The bench set aside in its entirety a ruling it had delivered barely a month earlier, on May 29, 2026, in the long-running dispute over the constitutionality of the National Social Security Fund (NSSF) Act, 2013. The May 29 ruling had dismissed NSSF’s application to suspend the enforcement of a 2022 Employment and Labour Relations Court (ELRC) judgment that declared the NSSF Act, 2013, unconstitutional. But the problem was stark and, as the bench put it, an “apparent error on the face of the record”: the application the court had purported to determine was no longer a live controversy before it. The parties had not been heard on it. In legal terms, the court had answered a question that nobody had asked.

The effect of the June 26 ruling is that the legal position reverts to where it stood before May 29. The substantive appeal on whether the NSSF Act, 2013, is constitutional or not remains pending before the Court of Appeal. There is currently no valid Court of Appeal ruling either granting or refusing a stay of the ELRC’s 2022 judgment.

Those who have been saying that we are going back to the KSh 200 monthly contributions are wrong.

A Decade of Legal Turbulence: The Road to This Ruling

To understand the significance of the June 26 ruling, one must appreciate the extraordinary procedural journey this dispute has taken.

The NSSF Act, 2013, fundamentally reimagined Kenya’s social security architecture. It replaced the long-standing flat monthly contribution of Ksh 200 from both employer and employee, a total of Ksh 400 per month, with a progressive, earnings-based contribution system.

Under a tiered structure, employees now contribute 6% of their pensionable earnings, matched equally by employers. In the current Year Four of implementation (effective February 2026), the Lower Earnings Limit stands at Ksh 9,000 and the Upper Earnings Limit at Ksh 108,000, meaning the maximum combined monthly contribution has risen dramatically to Ksh 12,960 for higher earners.

The law was challenged almost immediately. In September 2022, the ELRC declared the NSSF Act, 2013, unconstitutional on multiple grounds: that the Senate had not been involved in its enactment as required by the Constitution; that it violated competition law by unfairly favouring NSSF over private pension providers; that it unjustifiably restricted workers’ freedom of choice; and that it usurped the mandate of the Salaries and Remuneration Commission.

NSSF appealed, and in February 2023, the Court of Appeal reversed the ELRC’s decision, not on the merits, but on jurisdictional grounds, holding that the ELRC lacked the authority to hear such a constitutional matter in the first place. Enhanced contribution rates began rolling out in February 2023 on the strength of that decision.

The dispute then escalated to the Supreme Court, which in February 2024 overturned the Court of Appeal’s jurisdictional finding and ordered the appeal back to the Court of Appeal for a fresh hearing on the substantive merits. That is where the matter currently sits.

In this procedural maze, several applications had been filed. One of those, NSSF’s October 2022 application for a stay of the ELRC judgment pending determination of the appeal, had, according to the June 26 bench, been effectively overtaken by events, given the February 2023 Court of Appeal judgment and the subsequent Supreme Court proceedings. It was no longer a live application. The only pending matter before the court was an application filed in September 2024 by the Kenya Export Floriculture, Horticulture and Allied Workers Union, seeking to be joined in the proceedings as an interested party. That application had been heard in January 2025 and reserved for ruling.

Yet when the matter came up on May 29, 2026, the court inadvertently delivered a ruling on the defunct 2022 stay application rather than on the union’s joinder bid. As Senior Counsel Fred Ngatia, appearing for NSSF, aptly wrote to the court: “In plain terms, the Court purported to determine a motion which was neither before them nor was a live issue at all. A monumental error by any account.”

Related Content: NSSF Declares 17% Return For Its Members

The Legal Significance: Why Courts Can and Must Correct Themselves

The June 26 ruling carries layered significance for Kenyan procedural law. Courts of superior record do not frequently set aside their own decisions; the doctrine of functus officio, that a court’s authority over a matter ends once it delivers its judgment, generally prevents such self-correction. But the bench correctly identified that this principle cannot operate to protect an error so fundamental that it undermines the very foundation of due process.

The right to be heard, audi alteram partem, is not a procedural nicety. It is, as the bench itself stated, “a constitutional imperative.” The parties had simply not been heard on the application, the court determined on May 29. There was no hearing, no submissions, no contest. The court had essentially decided an issue from the sidelines of its own docket. To allow such a ruling to stand would have been to permit a grave injustice dressed up in judicial robes.

The bench’s willingness to invoke the “interests of justice” to correct an error of its own making is, in fact, commendable. The decision on costs was equally sound: because the error originated entirely from the court and not from the conduct of any party, each party was directed to bear its own costs. That is the correct outcome. It would be manifestly unfair to penalise any litigant for a mistake of the court’s own making.

What the Confusion Revealed: Institutional Fragility

The weeks between May 29 and June 26 were a case study in institutional fragility and the dangers that procedural errors can unleash at scale. Within days of the May 29 ruling, the Law Society of Kenya (LSK) declared there was “no judicial basis supporting the continued enforcement of the enhanced contribution framework.” Employers were confused.

The Federation of Kenya Employers (FKE) and the Central Organisation of Trade Unions (COTU), unlikely allies, joined NSSF in calling on employers to continue remitting enhanced contributions regardless. NSSF issued a public notice advising all stakeholders to “disregard misleading opinions” calling for a reversion to the Ksh 200 rate. A senator filed proceedings. The Consumers Federation of Kenya challenged NSSF’s June 5 directive in court.

All of this chaos, affecting millions of workers, thousands of employers, and a KSh 715 billion pension fund, flowed from one erroneous ruling. This is a powerful reminder that judicial error is never a purely academic matter. Where the subject is something as fundamental as the retirement savings of ordinary Kenyans, a procedural slip has real human consequences.

What This Means for Kenyans Currently Saving with NSSF

For the millions of salaried workers currently making NSSF contributions under the 2013 Act framework, the practical message from the June 26 ruling is this: nothing changes for now. The contribution deductions continue. The legal basis for those deductions, the NSSF Act, 2013, remains in force as the appeal proceeds. NSSF has been unequivocal: employers and employees should continue complying with the current framework.

The Broader Stakes: Social Security and the Retirement Crisis

Beyond the procedural drama lies a question of profound national importance. Kenya faces a looming retirement savings crisis. Only 20% of Kenyan workers have any retirement savings plan at all. The NSSF Act, 2013, was designed precisely to address this deficit by mandating meaningful, earnings-based contributions that would grow pension pools rather than tokenistically depositing Ksh 200 per month into accounts that inflation would render worthless.

The NSSF, now a Ksh 715 billion fund, has posted creditable returns, 11% to members in 2023/2024 and 17% in 2024/2025. These are not trivial numbers for a national pension fund navigating currency pressures and macroeconomic headwinds.

The constitutional arguments against the 2013 Act, Senate participation, competition fairness, and freedom of choice are legitimate legal questions that the courts are right to examine. But they should be resolved on their merits, not buried under procedural confusion or exploited to justify non-compliance that ultimately hurts workers, not employers.

Article 43(1)(e) of Kenya’s Constitution guarantees every person the right to social security. Article 21(2) places a positive obligation on the State to take progressive measures to realise that right. Whatever the courts ultimately decide about the NSSF Act, 2013’s procedural pedigree, the constitutional mandate is clear: Kenya must do better by its workers in retirement.

There is no doubt that the June 26 ruling is, at its core, a story about the administration of justice righting itself. The Court of Appeal identified an error, acknowledged it publicly, and corrected it, protecting the constitutional right of all parties to be heard before their interests are determined. That is not a weakness; it is the hallmark of a mature legal system.

But the ruling should also be read as a cautionary note. In a dispute of this magnitude, affecting the financial futures of millions of Kenyans and the architecture of the country’s social protection system, procedural errors are luxuries the justice system cannot afford. The substantive appeal must now proceed with dispatch. Kenyans deserve certainty on a matter that goes to the heart of their retirement dignity.

Related Content: Kenya’s NSSF Crisis: Why the Noise Around Contribution Rates Misses the Bigger Point

Business Watch Team

Business Watch Team

Business Watch is an online business portal that is set to marry both the traditional media and the digital media and bring them under one umbrella

Tweets by Business Watch

Archives

About

Business Watch is an online business portal that is set to marry both the traditional media and the digital media and bring them under one umbrella.

Ad

Our Detailed Reports

  1. [download id=”20060″]

Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from around Kenya and East Africa

Latest from Governance

Don't Miss